Vince answered a question at Quora.
VINCE DHIMOS ON QUORA: WITHOUT US SUPPORT, WOULD ISRAEL HAVE A HARD TIME DEFENDING ITSELF?
Without the US support, would Israel have a hard time defending itself?
Vince Dhimos, Editor-in-Chief at New Silk Strategies (2016-present)
Answered 22h ago
If Israel did not need a lot of help defending itself, there would be no need for the US to send $4.5 billion in aid every year.
But the defence is not the problem. The problem for Israel is that it is constantly crossing red lines at the UN and doing things that the UN considers illegal. Without US moral support, it would be obvious to everyone that this behaviour is reckless. In fact, it is reckless and can easily backfire on Israel by creating more and more enemies. But US power makes it appear less dangerous.
Israel needs the US to backstop it with moral and propaganda support. When the UN condemns Israel for firing missiles into Syria and Iraq, for example, these actions make it liable for legal action by other countries. However, the US, thanks to its extreme power and influence, blocks all legal actions and makes it impossible for anyone to discipline Israel.
If the US just stopped supporting Israel by blocking legal actions against it for various misdeeds, it would be harder for Israel to continue on its present path.
Let us remember that Arab countries are not the only impediment to Israel. Russia is the key. Russia has various means at its disposal, including military means, such as EW, which it has used to jam Israeli air travel to demonstrate that it can prevent Israel from attacking Iran, and also, the most powerful deterrent, ie, diplomacy. Just a few days ago, Israel and the US invited Russia to confer with them in Israel, and it was clear from the media commentaries that they wanted to pull Russia away from Iran by diplomatic and political means at this conference.
But Russian delegate Nikolai Patrushev nipped their intended goal in the bud by telling them that Iran was and always will be an ally. The message was crystal clear and was a new one: A war with Iran is a war with Russia. Assuming that the US and Israel are headed by even somewhat sane people, we can hope that this message will deter the US and Israel from attacking Iran.
END QUORA POST
I was inspired by an article I once read by Gideon Levy, the editor in chief of Israeli newspaper Haaretz. I was unable to find that article but the following column from Mint Press News conveys the gist of it nicely.
Human Rights Activist Gideon Levy: A Voice of Sanity from Israel
In spite of a systemic policy of demonization against him, Gideon Levy continues denouncing the Israeli government crimes against the Palestinians.
April 23rd, 2018
By Dr. Cesar Chelala
I first learned of Gideon Levy many years ago, during a casual conversation with an Israeli human rights activist. He told me that he had asked Levy why was he such a serious critic of Israel’s government and its policies with the Palestinians. Levy, whose own father was a German Jewish refugee who had settled in Israel, responded, “I don’t want Israelis to say that they didn’t know.”
Levy frequently travels to and writes about the Occupied Territories. As a columnist for the Israeli newspaper Haaretz, Levy wants to show the evils of the occupation and how it hurts not only the Palestinians but also the Israel that he loves so much. “I am an Israeli patriot. I want to be proud of my country. I want us to do the right thing,” he declared. His writing has gained him several prestigious awards, but also the hatred of many Israelis and several personal attacks.
Last March, on the eve of the official AIPAC (The American Israel Public Affairs Committee) summit, he gave a talk entitled, “The Zionist Tango: Step Left, Step Right” in the National Press Club in Washington, DC. In that talk, he touched upon many critical topics having to do with the occupation of the Palestinian Territories.
He spoke about the possibility of change within Israeli society. “Maybe you are holding the key for any kind of change, for any kind of hope because, as I’ll try to claim later on, the hope for change within Israeli society is so limited. It’s nonexistent. When the United States is so still, so crucial, people like you can make the difference.
People like you can really be a game changer, and I mean it. It was never before that Israel and the United States shared the same values like in those days. The only place on earth that Donald Trump is beloved, admired, adored, and appreciated is Israel. The only place that Benjamin Netanyahu is admired, adored and beloved is the United States. If this is not shared values, what is shared values?”
Levy doesn’t hide his contempt for the Jewish lobby in the United States, of which AIPAC is the most notorious organization. “I can tell you in the United States, as an Israeli, we don’t have a bigger enemy for justice, for peace, for equality than those who think that if you supply the drug addict with more drugs you are his friend; that if you support him blindly and automatically whatever he does, you are a friend. No, my friend, those are not friends. Those are enemies.”
Levy calls the recent actions of Israeli soldiers in Gaza crimes against civilians, hardly covered by the media. Ahed Tamimi is a 17-year-od Palestinian girl whose family demonstrated their opposition to the expansion of the Israeli settlements and the detention of Palestinian activists. When she was 11 years-old, Ahed was commended for her courage by the President of the Palestinian National Authority Mahmoud Abbas for attempting to prevent her mother’s detention in August 2012.
In 2015, she was filmed while she was biting a masked Israeli soldier who was trying to apprehend her brother for throwing stones against the soldiers. On December 15, 2017, Ahed took part in a demonstration opposing the expansion of Israeli settlements near her village. During the protest, Ahed’s 15-year-old cousin Mohammed Tamimi was shot in the head and severely wounded. Ahed, along with mother and a cousin slapped, kicked and shoved the soldiers.
Four days later, Ahed was arrested with her mother and her cousin and charged with assault and incitement to violence. She instantly became a symbol of Palestinian resistance to the Israeli occupation in the West Bank. Major rallies in her support took place in several major cities in the U.S. and Europe.
Levy is unsparing in his criticism of the Israeli soldiers’ actions. “The crimes [by the Israeli soldiers] are on a daily basis, but really daily basis. The media hardly covers them. If they cover them, it will be always according to the Zionist narrative. A terrorist of 12, a girl of 14 with scissors in her hands is an existential threat to the State of Israel. A girl who is slapping a soldier is someone who deserves life in prison, not less than this.”
I remember my surprise, several years ago, when I found out that an Israeli professional acquaintance of mine had never, aside from his gardener, had a conversation with any other Palestinian, although he was living in Jerusalem. Levy explains, “…Everyone will deny it. But if you scratch under the skin of almost every Israeli, you’ll find it there. The Palestinians are not equal human beings like us. They are not like us. They don’t love their children like us. They don’t love life like us…
So you have a society with a deep conviction in its justice, in its right way with very, very few question marks. Anyone who dares to raise a question mark in a systematic way is immediately erased, demolished. It is unbelievable how this machinery works for Israel.”
In spite of a systemic policy of demonization against him, Gideon Levy continues denouncing the Israeli government crimes against the Palestinians, who have been unable to counteract this onslaught against their basic rights. Gideon Levy is their defender, and Israel’s voice of sanity.
Dr. Cesar Chelala is a co-winner of the 1979 Overseas Press Club of America award for the article “Missing or Disappeared in Argentina: The Desperate Search for Thousands of Abducted Victims.”
© Consortium News